As Retirement Nears, Clinton County Prosecutor Reflects on Brandy Wilson’s Disappearance

FRANKFORT, Ind. — As Clinton County Prosecutor Tony Sommer prepares to retire, he says one case still troubles him: the disappearance of Brandy Wilson, a 24-year-old Colfax mother who has been missing since June 4, 2002. Sommer said Friday, Nov. 20, on WILO’s “Party Line” that investigators have revisited the case during his tenure but have never submitted it to him for a charging decision.

Clinton County Prosecutor Tony Sommer talks about his time as Clinton County Proscutor and what it feels like to have 42 days left until retirement.  Cindy Loveless and Sam Wort hosted the program broadcast LIVE on WILO 96.9 FM, Boone 102.7 FM, WILO 1570 and Hoosierland TV.

In the interview, Sommer also discussed the transition to his successor, called for tougher penalties in fatal impaired-driving cases and explained how Indiana verifies ballots cast in person and by mail.

Brandy Wilson case remains unresolved

Sommer said he first learned about Wilson’s disappearance while working as an Indiana State Police detective assigned to the Lafayette Post. He said detectives from the post helped investigate the case, though he did not work on it himself.

Since taking office, Sommer said, he has spoken with investigators who have tried to move the case forward. He cited a lack of physical evidence and evidence that could be admitted in court. “They’ve never submitted a case to me for a charging decision,” he said.

The discussion followed a question about a separate case in neighboring Carroll County. The FBI is offering up to $50,000 for information leading to an arrest in the Nov. 21, 2016, arson that killed four sisters in Flora.

 Vawter prepares to take office

Clinton County Assistant Prosecutor Chris Vawter gives legal perspectives on what happens to those involved with swatting (False Emergency Report).  Photo from Clinton County Daily News Archive.

Sommer said his successor, deputy prosecutor Christopher David Vawter Jr., has worked with him for a little more than 10 years. Vawter ran unopposed in the November general election.

Sommer said Vawter has helped prepare the office’s budget, is familiar with its pending cases and has established working relationships with local law enforcement and defense attorneys. He said one of his remaining priorities is making sure Vawter has the staff he needs.

Sommer calls for tougher impaired-driving penalties

Sommer said Indiana should make operating while intoxicated resulting in death a Level 3 or Level 2 felony. State law classifies operating while intoxicated and causing death or catastrophic injury as a Level 4 felony, which carries a standard prison term of two to 12 years.

Clinton County Courthouse Clock Tower Watercolor based on a photo by Russ Kaspar

“I’m still at a point where I want it closer to the penalties that are available for a murder,” Sommer said. He drew on his experience investigating fatal crashes as a state trooper and prosecuting them in Clinton County. He said repeat offenders were a particular concern, while acknowledging that a first-time offender can also cause a fatal crash.

Sommer said one of the hardest parts of his job is explaining to families why a fatal crash does not always lead to criminal charges. A driver may be civilly liable for a crash, he said, without the facts supporting a criminal prosecution.

Voter ID, mail ballots and recounts

Sommer described voting with someone else’s identification as one example of voter fraud. He pointed to Indiana’s photo ID requirement for most in-person voters and signature checks for absentee ballots returned by mail.

Sommer said differences in state rules, including deadlines for receiving mailed ballots, can affect how quickly results are available. He also noted that candidates can seek recounts and may have to pay associated costs. “Sometimes in a tight race a few votes will change the outcome,” he said.